Peanut Butterfinger Cream Pie

Level: Easy
Prep Time: 10 min
Cook Time:
Cooling Time: 3 hrs
Yields: 8


This cream pie made with peanut butter and butterfinger candy is a great make-ahead dessert that only takes minutes to put together.


  • 1 prepared 9-inch (6 to 8 oz.) chocolate cookie crust
  • 1 package (8 oz.) cream cheese, at room temperature
  • 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter
  • 1 1/2 cups powdered sugar
  • 1 (2.1 oz.) NESTLÉ BUTTERFINGER Candy Bar, chopped
  • 2 cups whipping cream, whipped
  • 1/4 cup NESTLÉ NESQUIK Chocolate Flavor Syrup


BEAT cream cheese and peanut butter in large mixer bowl until smooth. Beat in powdered sugar. Stir in chopped Butterfinger. Fold in whipped cream. Spread into cookie crust.

REFRIGERATE for 3 to 4 hours. Drizzle with Nesquik before serving.

taste great

by A. Amanda , lomita on Jan. 2011

it seems very easy to make & my family loves it!

Wonderful dessert

by R. ROBERTA , LOUDON, TN on Sep. 2008

I substituted tart shells for the chocolate pie shell and spread hot fudge sundae topping on the bottom of the shell before adding the peanut butterfinger cream for the dessert buffet at my daughter's wedding. I lost track of the compliments!


by M. Mariane , Kingston, ON on Jan. 2008

I made this pie for a dinner party and it was a hit! Everyone loved it and most went for seconds! I made it with light cool whip, light cream cheese and natural peanut butter and it turned out great! I will definitely be making this again!

Wonderfully Good Pie

by M. Margie , Pell City, Al on Apr. 2007

I think that this is one of the best pies I have made. It is rich. But very light to eat. So easy to make. My husband took it to work and they say it is on "top of the list" for desserts to make. I will be making this again and again. Thank you. God bless you....

Peanut Butterfinger Cream Pie

by R. RUBY , JERUSALEM, OH on Feb. 2007

This was easy to make but was sooo rich. My kids and grandkids just loved it but to a adult its very rich. Good for the picky eater in your family that likes to eat something sweet! Tastes Good and Rich!

Looked great but didn't like it

by S. Sandra , FORT KNOX, KY on Oct. 2006

Didn't care for this much, took to a friends house and nobody cared for it either. It was on the rich side but I didn't care for the consistency of it either.

Great Peanut Butterfiner Cream Pie

by D. Dena , WINTERSET, IA on Oct. 2006

This pie was simple to make. Taste really great. I did add another butterfinger candy bar than what the recipe called for so that it tasted even better.

Peanutbutter Pie

by J. Julia , Sparta, TN on Sep. 2006

I have made this pie for many years. I get moans and groans every single time. (This is of course a good thing!) I also crumble a second Butterfinger candy bar on top.

What a Hit!

by K. Kathy , ALPHARETTA, GA on Aug. 2006

I made this for the Butterfinger lovers in my family(which is almost everyone). They loved it! I can't wait to take this pie to our next church social!

One of the best deserts I have ever made

by E. Emily , Petaluma, CA on Jun. 2006

I found on the back of my chocolate chips bag and was so delighted when I visited this website.This is the second recipe I have tried, although i did enjoy the first recipe, I absolutely loved this recipe for Peanut Butterfinger Cream Pie.This recipe is delicious. I enjoy baking and I am always looking for new recipes to try. Butterfinger candy bars are my favorite. I am delighted to have found such a excellent recipe. So rich and creamy. Easy to make and a real treat. Thank you.